Pulitzer Prize: Biography or Autobiography
- 2008 Eden's Outcasts John Matteson (W.W. Norton)
- 2007 The Most Famous Man in America Debby Applegate
- 2006 American Prometheus: The Triumph and Tragedy of J. Robert Oppenheimer Kai Bird and Martin J. Sherwin
- 2005 de Kooning: An American Master Mark Stevens and Annalyn Swan
- 2004 Khrushchev: The Man and His Era William Taubman
- 2003 Master of the Senate: The Years of Lyndon Johnson vol. 3 Robert A. Caro
- 2002 John Adams David McCullough
- 2001 W E B DuBois (volume 2) David Levering Lewis
- 2000 Vera Stacy Schiff
- 1999 Lindbergh A. Scott Berg
- 1998 Personal history Katharine Graham
- 1997 Angela's ashes Frank McCourt
- 1996 God: A biography Jack Miles
- 1995 No ordinary time Doris Kearns Goodwin
- 1994 W. E. B. DuBois D. Lewis
- 1993 Truman David McCullough
- 1992 Fortunate Son: The Healing of a Vietnam vet Lewis B. Puller Jr.
- 1991 Jackson Pollock: An American saga Steven Naifeh and Gregory White Smith
- 1990 Machiavelli in hell Sebastian Grazia
- 1989 Oscar Wilde Richard Ellmann
- 1988 Look homeward: A life of Thomas Wolfe David Herbert Donald
- 1987 Bearing the cross: Martin Luther King Jr. and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference David J. Garrow
- 1986 Louise Bogan: A portrait Elizabeth Frank
- 1985 The Life and times of Cotton Mather Kenneth Silverman
- 1984 Booker T. Washington: The Wizard of Tuskegee 1901-1915 Louis R. Harlan
- 1983 Growing up Russell Baker
- 1982 Grant: A Biography William S. McFeely
- 1981 Peter the Great: His life and world Robert K. Massie
- 1980 The Rise of Theodore Roosevelt Edmund Morris
- 1979 Days of sorrow and pain: Leo Baeck and the Berlin Jews Leonard Baker
- 1978 Samuel Johnson Walter Jackson Bate
- 1977 A Prince of our disorder: The Life of T.E. Lawrence John E. Mack
- 1976 Edith Wharton: A biography R.W.B. Lewis
- 1975 The Power broker: Robert Moses and the fall of New York Robert Caro
- 1974 O’Neill, son and artist Louis Sheaffer
- 1973 Luce and his empire W.A. Swanberg
- 1972 Eleanor and Franklin Joseph P. Lash
- 1971 Robert Frost: The Years of triumph 1915-1938 Lawrence Thompson
- 1970 Huey Long T. Harry Williams
- 1969 The Man from New York: John Quinn and his friends Benjamin Lawrence Reid
- 1968 Memoirs George F. Kennan
- 1967 Mr. Clemens and Mark Twain Justin Kaplan
- 1966 A Thousand days: J F Kennedy in the White House Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr.
- 1965 Henry Adams (three volumes) Ernest Samuels
- 1964 John Keats Walter Jackson Bate
- 1963 Henry James Leon Edel
- 1962 No Award
- 1961 Charles Sumner and the coming of the Civil War David Donald
- 1960 John Paul Jones Samuel Eliot Morison
- 1959 Woodrow Wilson American prophet Arthur Walworth
- 1958 George Washington Volumes I-VI Douglas S. Freeman and Volume VII written John Alexander Carroll and Mary Wells Ashworth after Dr. Freeman’s death
- 1957 Profiles in courage John F. Kennedy
- 1956 Benjamin Henry Latrobe Talbot Faulkner Hamlin
- 1955 The Taft story William S. White
- 1954 The Spirit of St. Louis Charles A. Lindbergh
- 1953 Edmund Pendleton, 1721-1803 David J. Mays
- 1952 Charles Evans Hughes Merlo J. Pusey
- 1951 John C. Calhoun: American portrait Margaret Louise Coit
- 1950 John Quincy Adams and the foundations of American foreign policy Samuel Flagg Bemis
- 1949 Roosevelt and Hopkins Robert E. Sherwood
- 1948 Forgotten first citizen: John Bigelow Margaret Clapp
- 1947 The Autobiography of William Allen White William Allen White
- 1946 Son of the wilderness Linnie Marsh Wolfe
- 1945 George Bancroft: Brahmin rebel Russell Blaine Nye
- 1944 The American Leonardo: the life of Samuel F. B. Morse Carlton Mabee
- 1943 Admiral of the ocean sea: a life of Christopher Columbus Samuel Eliot Morison
- 1942 Crusader in crinoline: a life of Harriet Beecher Stowe Forrest Wilson
- 1941 Jonathan Edwards Ola Elizabeth Winslow
- 1940 Woodrow Wilson, life and letters Volumes VII and VIII Ray Stannard Baker
- 1939 Benjamin Franklin Carl Van Doren
- 1938 Andrew Jackson (2 volumes) Marquis James; Pedlar’s progress Odell Shepard
- 1937 Hamilton Fish Allan Nevins
- 1936 The Thought and character of William James Ralph Barton Perry
- 1935 R.E. Lee Douglas S. Freeman
- 1934 John Hay Tyler Dennett
- 1933 Grover Cleveland Allan Nevins
- 1932 Theodore Roosevelt Henry F. Pringle
- 1931 Charles W. Eliot Henry James
- 1930 The Raven Marquis James
- 1929 The Training of an American: The Earlier life and letters of Walter H. Page Burton J. Hendrick
- 1928 The American orchestra and Theodore Thomas Charles Edward Russell
- 1927 Whitman Emory Holloway
- 1926 The Life of Sir William Osler (2 volumes) Harvey Cushing
- 1925 Barrett Wendell and his letter M.A. DeWolfe Howe
- 1924 From immigrant to inventor Michael Idvorsky Pupin
- 1923 The Life and letters of Walter H. Page Burton J. Hendrick
- 1922 A Daughter of the middle border Hamlin Garland
- 1921 The Americanization of Edward Bok Edward Bok
- 1920 The Life of John Marshall (4 volumes) Albert J. Beveridge
- 1919 The Education of Henry Adams Henry Adams
- 1918 Benjamin Franklin self-revealed William Cabell Bruce
- 1917 Julia Ward Howe Laura E. Richards and Maude Howe Elliott, assisted by Florence Howe Hall

